- The Conversion Ledger
- Posts
- The most abused CRO tactic on the internet
The most abused CRO tactic on the internet
Urgency works... until it doesn’t. Here’s how to use it without destroying trust.
Brian Schmitt
November 09, 2025
Urgency That Converts vs. Urgency That Corrodes Trust
You’ve probably run a test with urgency messaging.
Maybe it was a countdown timer.
Maybe a “few left in stock” nudge.
Maybe it was something like:
“Ends tonight!”
“Hurry! Last chance!”
“100+ sold today!”
Sometimes they work.
Sometimes they do nothing.
Sometimes they tank transactions or cause customer complaints.
So what gives?
Here’s what we’ve learned after running hundreds of these tests across ecomm brands of all sizes:
Urgency isn’t just about the words. It’s about timing, context, and trust.
Let’s unpack that.
1. There’s more than one kind of urgency.
There are three core types:
Supply-based – “Only 3 left”
Demand-based – “500 sold today”
Time-based – “Sale ends at midnight”
Each of these triggers different psychological responses.
And they don’t work the same way for every audience or product.
Supply-based urgency works best for uniqueness-seeking buyers.
Demand-based is stronger for conformity-driven buyers.
Time-based urgency can backfire if the deadline feels fake.
2. Product type matters.
Urgency for a $38 water bottle? Works like a charm.
Urgency for a $2,800 sofa? Kills trust.
On lower-ticket, utilitarian items, urgency often acts as a helpful nudge.
On high-ticket, high-consideration products, it can raise red flags.
The higher the price or involvement, the more authenticity matters.
Win of the Week:
Problem:
Product Detail Pages (PDPs) weren’t offering enough subtle reinforcement to help hesitant shoppers feel confident about purchasing. Without any peer cues or urgency signals, many users browsed without taking action.
Discovery:
Session data showed that shoppers lingered on PDPs without engaging. The hypothesis emerged from a behavioral insight: seeing that others are interested in a product (via real-time cart data) might help move shoppers off the fence.
Hypothesis:
If we show how many people currently have an item in their cart, shoppers will feel more confident in their interest, reducing friction and nudging them toward adding to cart and purchasing.
Test:
A new PDP tag was added displaying:
📣 “28+ people have this in their cart”
Results:
+4% lift in add-to-carts
+3.7% lift in checkout visits
+7.8% lift in transactions
→ $1,009,948 in projected annual mobile revenue
Lesson:
Real-time social proof helps shoppers feel less alone in their interests.
It’s not pressure, it’s reassurance. When placed thoughtfully, even a small nudge like “others are buying this” can drive meaningful lift.
The “Good Urgency” Checklist
• Backed by real data (not just recycled every visit)
• Matched to product price & involvement
• Designed for clarity, not pressure
• Segment-aware (new vs returning, mobile vs desktop)
When urgency works
One of our clients saw a 3.65% lift in transactions from a clever urgency tactic:
Triggering a red banner when a user highlighted the product title — something deal-seekers often do before Google searching a coupon.
It reassured users they were already getting the best price.
No pressure. No manipulation.
Just contextual, behavioral urgency.
When urgency fails
We’ve also seen urgency messages increase cart adds…
Only to drop AOV and hurt final conversions.
Why?
Because people panic-add to cart…
Then re-evaluate during checkout and bounce.
Urgency got the click, but not the conversion.
That’s why we always measure beyond just cart adds.
Quote of the week:
people seem to be more motivated by the thought of losing something than by the thought of gaining something of equal value.
Take this with you:
Urgency done right builds confidence. Urgency done wrong erodes it.
If your tactic wouldn’t pass the sniff test with your own mother?
Don’t run it.
Instead, ask:
Does this urgency message actually match how my inventory works?
Am I telling the truth, or just manufacturing FOMO?
What will this feel like to a shopper seeing it for the first time?
Because long-term trust always beats short-term tricks.
Looking forward,
How valuable was this week's newsletter? |
P.S. Ready to grow revenue without having to grow traffic? Let’s talk.